After the overwhelming success of the last (and first) Extra Dark episode, Caroline Weaver, Caitlin Elgin and the guys get together after recording Episode 65 to talk about the recently released Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life special season on Netflix. Spoiler: Nope, they didn't much care for it, and yep, Johnny still has the hots for Emily Gilmore. Warning: Lots of Naughty Words.

After recording episode 45, Caroline, Caitlin, Johnny, Tim and Andy continued their discussion, but not about pencils. No, they spent 33 minutes discussing The Gilmore Girls. They discuss their favorite dateable stars, predictions for the revival coming to Netflix soon. And you don't even want to know how Johnny feels about Kelly Bishop.

With our most heartfelt apologies to Amy Sherman-Palladino.